Does the Kauai County Council have the legal authority to require biotech companies to disclose specifics about their pesticide use?
Can the county require buffer zones between fields that are being sprayed with pesticides and public areas, such as schools and roads?
Can it require studies on the effects of pesticides and GMOs on human health and the environment?
These questions have been at the forefront of the debate over Bill 2491. Attorneys for the bitoech companies have said in past hearings that the county doesn’t have this power and that aspects of the bill could be overturned in a legal battle because they are “vague and ambiguous” or amount to an “illegal taking” of property.
But a cadre of local attorneys are now speaking out in support of the county’s authority to implement the bill, which was amended on Friday to focus more narrowly on pesticides.
In a statement released Wednesday, nine attorneys say that County council members should not be swayed by the biotech industry’s threats of lawsuits.
The statement reads in part:
No thoughtful, experienced attorney will offer blanket assurances about how any lawsuit will be decided, and the bill presents some cutting-edge legal issues. But the State expressly granted the County the authority to protect the health, life, and property of its people from just these kinds of threats. No law expressly prohibits the County from taking this action, and no court cases clearly block the County from passing and implementing this Bill. Moreover, ordinances with similar provisions have been passed elsewhere and have not been successfully challenged.
We believe that Bill 2491 is sound, and the mere threat of a lawsuit by industry interests should not prevent the Council from taking action they believe is
About the Author
Mr. Caldwell’s Penguins
Mayor Kirk Caldwell will be “welcoming” four endangered African penguins to the Honolulu Zoo on Wednesday, according to a press release. Photo op at 1:30 p.m. So how does one welcome a penguin?
SCOTUS Asked To Review Nai Aupuni
The Grassroot Institute has taken its case to stop the Nai Aupuni election to the U.S. Supreme Court, after lower courts declined to halt the process.
The Last Telescope
UH President David Lassner says in a letter to the Department of Land and Natural Resources that the Thirty Meter Telescope will be the last one built in that area on Mauna Kea.
But there’s hope around planned rail stations where the city administration wants to concentrate growth.
A time-of-use pilot project on Kauai is expected to bring down costs for people who sign up for it. But it could have future payoffs for all customers.
The past 12 days have focused a spotlight not only on troubling events in Europe and Africa, but on an unseemly wave of panic sweeping America.
The Labor Department says Tomasita Farm Service paid 65 migrant workers from Mexico and Micronesia well below minimum wage.
The $6.6 billion project hangs in the balance until Honolulu’s City Council votes on a 5-year tax extension to cover a $1 billion-plus deficit.
The signs are hard to regulate because they’re put up and taken down before city enforcement can get to them.
Plenty of traditionally trained medical professionals cite evidence that supports many alternative approaches to health care. It’s not an either/or situation.
The SAT and ACT are warmed-over versions of the old IQ tests, but there are much better ways to assess our students today, if only we would use them.
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell signed five bills into law Monday on issues from property taxes to discrimination against women.
Lots of money is being spent in the western U.S. to build rail lines. From Denver to LA to Honolulu, federal officials want to know whether the FTA is doing a good job overseeing those projects.
New Civil Beat columnist: The illusory promise of paradise obscures Hawaii’s fundamental problems.
Peter Apo’s roots may have saved his life when he was on the West Coast. Now he is working to facilitate federal recognition for Hawaiians.
Attorney Eric Seitz joins the Pod Squad to talk about two of his cases: two lesbians recently arrested for kissing in public and a man who died after being shot with a Taser.
Only five weeks remain for public comment on a federal rule to govern relations between the United States and a Native Hawaiian government.
Congress panders as it passes a bill pointlessly targeting Iraqi and Syrian refugees. Also: Iran draws down under the new nuclear deal, and Sand Island moves forward.
Hawaiian Electric wants to offer shockingly lower rates to customers — at least for part of the day.
Six residents are the first to move in to a facility that’s been in the planning stages for more than a year.
In the past two months, 79 cases have been confirmed on the Big Island.
Options will be available to view transcripts of the Hawaii PUC hearing without spending thousands of dollars to buy them from the court reporter.
Under a court-sanctioned agreement, the city’s maintenance crew cannot immediately dispose of most items taken while clearing out homeless encampments.
Rumors are swirling, but Scott Morishige says any action on the state-owned land in Waianae would be based on input from the community and service providers.
For better or worse, millennials can’t look away. They are caring and civic minded, whether the injustices they perceive are trivial or of global importance.