Of the many things to say regarding last week’s unfortunate adoption of a new media policy by members of the Honolulu Ethics Commission, chief among them is this:
What were they thinking?
The seven-member panel approved a new policy effectively muzzling the commission’s executive director, Chuck Totto, requiring him to seek approval before discussing decisions or opinions with the press. The commission would have the public believe this is a desirable way to promote public understanding of its sometimes complex and nuanced decisions.
But no one’s buying it.
As Civil Beat’s Nick Grube reported, the commission only became interested in a new policy after Executive Director Chuck Totto spoke out on several matters involving Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell. The three commissioners most involved in creating the policy — including its author, Commissioner Riki May Amano — are all former judges who were appointed by Caldwell to the commission over the past year. Thus, the guidelines not only deal a blow to the commission’s own credibility, but cast a pall over the Caldwell administration, as well.
Moreover, the guidelines were only approved after Totto reportedly made comments to media following the commission’s action on 72 ethics violations by former Honolulu City Councilman Nestor Garcia that resulted in an $8,100 fine.
Totto suggested that because Garcia didn’t disclose conflicts of interest before casting votes, those votes
Big Island Mayor Billy Kenoi’s questionable purchases on a county charge card has prompted the Honolulu Mayor’s Office to release information on how Hawaii’s largest city handles the special charge cards.
On Thursday, Mayor Kirk Caldwell’s spokesman Jesse Broder Van Dyke issued a lengthy fact sheet outlining the city’s purchasing card policies.
Broder Van Dyke said the city had received numerous requests for information about Honolulu’s use of the cards after Kenoi’s troubles were widely publicized.
The fact sheet makes clear that Caldwell, unlike Kenoi, does not have a “pCard,” — a purchasing card — and that he pays for his travel expenses out-of-pocket and is then reimbursed.
In a series of Q&As, Broder Van Dyke noted that there are 636 active pCards in city government along with another 107 in use at the Honolulu Board of Water Supply.
He said that no city employees have had their pCards removed for improper use over the past five years. He also provided a list of all employees who have pCards.
Supporting all of this are documents attached to the fact sheet, including a full list of employees with pCards, the city’s pCard policy and a summary of Caldwell’s travel expenses from Jan. 1, 2013 to March 31, 2015.
You can read all those documents here:
Honolulu pCard policy from Civil Beat
Caldwell’s travel summary from Civil Beat
Editor’s note: Our exploration of urban design, planning and architecture in Hawaii is continuing with the addition of a familiar voice. Curt Sanburn grew up in Honolulu and graduated from Iolani School before venturing to the mainland and Yale. He later helped to found the Honolulu Weekly, becoming a regular contributor and editor. Curt often wrote critically about local architecture and land-use issues. “Hawaii deserves the best built environment in the world,” he says, “but it so often comes up short.”
What a stupid, meaningless phrase, especially in Hawaii, where we’re pretty sure we’re already living in God’s own paradise and everything else isn’t relevant. The only people who use the term are politicians and bad travel writers, or those who are selling something, or in Philadelphia.
Nevertheless, here we are in Honolulu, clucking about becoming world class even as we sink into third-world metrics, with a 20-mile elevated heavy-rail transit line, circa 1962, ready to mire us ever deeper into penury and ugliness.
The city needs cash. It owns 22 acres of hot real estate, known to locals as the Blaisdell Center.
Coincidentally, it’s just mauka of Kakaako, where big money and big construction unions are happily sloshing around building a mini-Hong Kong. The planned Kakaako transit stop
Mayor Kirk Caldwell stressed the need to move forward on the Honolulu rail project with an extension of the General Excise Tax during his 2015 State of the City address Tuesday while emphasizing the progress he has made since taking office two years ago on road repaving, park rejuvenation, bike lanes and the homelessness problem.
With the rail project — the biggest public works project in the state’s history — facing a $900 million shortfall with only two miles of the 20-mile guideway built, Caldwell vowed not to run from the political quagmire.
“Rail is the big elephant in this very big, outdoor room and we need to talk about it,” Caldwell told an audience of about 150 invited guests who convened on a grassy plot at Foster Botanical Garden in downtown Honolulu. “As a politician, I’m not going to run from it, I’m not going to blame anyone, I’m not going to look backwards and say, ‘Why didn’t you do this or that?’ I accept that this is happening under my watch.”
Caldwell’s remarks came after criticism last month that he was dodging the problem and trying to hand off responsibility to Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation Executive Director Dan Grabauskas, a political appointee.
Caldwell has been lobbying the Legislature and top state officials to extend the half percent surcharge
Editor’s Note: “Off Track,” our investigative series examining what’s happening to $6 billion in taxpayer money that is going into the biggest public works project in Hawaii history, continues today with a look at campaign contributions from contractors to local politicians. That may seem like an obvious political story but our larger question remains: Is the Honolulu rail project boosting the economy — as Oahu voters were promised — or just fattening the campaign treasuries of politicians in a position to hand out lucrative contracts? We need your help to figure out who’s really benefitting from the rail project. Check out the list of companies posted at the end of this story. Who are these companies and are they really locally owned and operated? Have you or anyone you know gotten a job with any of them? Do you own or work for a business that has benefitted from rail money? Increased sales? Better salaries? What are some of the economic indicators you’ve seen that would suggest rail is having an impact on our economy? Help us tell this important story through crowdsourcing. Post your thoughts in the comments section below or send a note to Nick Grube at firstname.lastname@example.org. Continue the conversation in our Facebook Group, Honolulu Rail Talk, or through Twitter or Instagram using the hashtag #railtalk.
Many of the companies snatching up contracts as part of Honolulu’s $6 billion rail project are also the same ones plumping up the campaign coffers of local politicians.
A handful of Hawaii-based businesses alone
Mayor Kirk Caldwell’s administration is hiring a consultant to help assess whether it’s safe to relocate some 100 homeless people to a vacant lot on Sand Island after reports surfaced in September that the soil could contain high levels of contaminants left over from ash and solid waste dumps.
The consultant is expected to work with state health officials to compile the industrial history of the proposed 5-acre site and develop a plan to sample the soil for contaminants such as lead, according to Gary Gill, deputy director for environmental health at the state health department.
Exposure to high levels of lead, a heavy metal associated with incinerator ash, is linked to kidney and brain damage, as well as mental retardation in children, birth defects, miscarriage and infertility, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The environmental assessment could delay the city’s plans to renovate the site to accommodate homeless individuals and families. The Caldwell administration had hoped to have the lot ready by the end of this month, paving a portion of it to contain any chemical contamination, and providing portable toilets, showers and lockers for homeless to use. The homeless would be required to bring their own tents.
However, Gill said that sampling alone would likely take longer than a month.
Proposal Was Key to Sit-Lie Ban
Dozens of people crowded into a small cafeteria at Puuhale Elementary School in Kalihi Wednesday evening to hear city officials discuss recently announced plans to relocate as many as 100 of the city’s most troubled homeless people to a vacant parcel of land on Sand Island.
The meeting was called primarily to address community concerns about the proposal to place a homeless encampment close to residents of Kalihi.
From the elementary school, it is a nearly two-mile drive to the proposed site. To reach the encampment, people must cross the bridge to Sand Island, a heavily industrial area where there are many Matson shipping containers, municipal recycling operations, the city’s sewage treatment plant and dozens of other businesses and warehouses.
A few residents and Sand Island ocean users raised objections to the plan, saying homeless people at the camp might spread out into the Sand Island beach park and the Kalihi community, leading to concerns about increased drug use and safety in
With the primary elections behind us, forums and sign waving for candidates for the November elections are already underway.
And many of us in the public are cringing at the expectation of being inundated by advertising for or against candidates, sponsored not by the candidates but by funds provided to Super PACs from secret donors operating “independently” of the candidates. (Remember all the negative ads in the 2010 Honolulu mayor’s race?)
The Supreme Court 2010 rulings in Citizen’s United vs. the FEC and other cases opened the floodgates of money attempting to influence elections and gain influence with the politicians who are elected.
This year, as Republicans work to hold the U.S. House of Representatives and gain control of the Senate, as well as capture as many governorships as possible, and as Democrats are equally committed to preventing this, we may expect to see a much greater influx of money into Hawaii elections than we have previously seen.
Is there no way to stop this?
Perhaps there is. In 2012, Elizabeth Warren and Scott Brown, running for the U.S. Senate in Massachusetts, pioneered what has come to be called “The People’s Pledge.” They agreed to make charitable donations from their campaign funds equal to half of any money spent for advertising on their behalf by “independent” outside groups. Their
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell’s first term isn’t up until 2016, but that hasn’t stopped him from padding his campaign reserves.
Caldwell reported more than $1.4 million in campaign contributions during the current election cycle, which began Nov. 7, 2012, the day after he beat former Hawaii Gov. Ben Cayetano in the general election.
What’s striking is Caldwell only raised $1.7 million for the entire 2012 election cycle, which included a $50,000 loan.
If Caldwell’s current fundraising trends continue, the mayor could have more than $3 million in the bank to help fend off any potential challengers.
And it’s entirely possible he’ll need every penny.
Former Honolulu Mayor Peter Carlisle — who Caldwell and Cayetano pushed out during the 2012 primary — has said he would like to run again.
Another viable candidate is Honolulu City Council Chair Ernie Martin, who won re-election Saturday to his seat in District 2, which includes Wahiawa, the North Shore and much of Windward Oahu.
Martin has said before that he wants to be mayor. He’s also been in the middle of some public feuds with Caldwell and his administration, over everything from budgetary earmarks to combating homelessness.
While Hawaii Campaign Spending data shows Carlisle has been relatively inactive ever since losing the 2012 election, Martin’s latest financial report shows that as of July 25 he had $327,000 in cash on hand.
Hurricane Iselle, the first hurricane that could hit the Big island in more than 20 years, was steadily churning toward Hilo and expected to make landfall Thursday.
Meanwhile, Hurricane Julio is advancing toward the islands and could strike the Big Island as soon as Sunday. On Wednesday evening, Julio was 1,450 miles east of Hilo, about 1,000 miles behind Iselle.
On Wednesday, Iselle was considered a category 1 hurricane. On Tuesday evening it appeared as though the cyclone was weakening, but then it started to strengthen Wednesday. It’s expected to make its way across the rest of the state on Friday.
“Because it’s maintaining its strength right now, it’s minimizing the likelihood that it’s going to weaken,” National Weather Service meteorologist Michael Cantin said Wednesday afternoon. “It’ll be a rough end of the week for us.”
Officials are saying little about Julio at this point, noting that it’s still too far away from the archipelago to speculate about its impact on the islands.
A hurricane warning has been issued for the Big Island — the first such advisory to be issued for the island in more than a decade — while a flash flood watch is in effect across the entire state through Saturday morning. As of Wednesday afternoon, tropical storm warnings had been issued for most
Two measures proposed by Mayor Kirk Caldwell that would ban public urination and defecation in Waikiki, as well as sitting and lying on sidewalks in the tourist district, were deferred indefinitely by the Honolulu City Council’s Zoning and Planning Committee on Thursday.
The bills are part of a larger so-called “compassionate disruption” campaign aimed at prodding homeless into shelters. But councilmembers said that the city hasn’t moved fast enough to make housing available to homeless living on the streets and that for now they have nowhere to go.
Caldwell has made reducing homelessness on Oahu a top priority of his administration and the City Council has appropriated more than $47 million this fiscal year for that effort. But it will likely take the city several years to create much of the needed housing.
At first, the bills introduced by the mayor last month seemed to be getting good traction in the City Council. Chair Ernie Martin even fast tracked them, noting that “homelessness has reached a crisis stage in Honolulu.”
Other council members seemed to agree that they were necessary, though they also worried that the Waikiki bills would push the homeless not into shelters, but into their own districts.
To that end, Councilwoman Carol Fukunaga introduced a bill that would extend the sidewalk prohibitions to Chinatown. And on Thursday morning, Councilman Ron Menor introduced a measure that would expand the sit-lie ban to areas
Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell wants to boost his budget by 70 percent, which is more than any other city department.
The rail project is on track now that legal wrangling is complete, but will there be more unexpected costs?
Public money is at heart of bid to save affordable housing sale.
Ethics Commission and Caldwell administration resolve some differences, but there’s a long way to go.